Henri Cartier-Bresson, Early Prints @Houk

JTF (just the facts): A total of 49 vintage/early gelatin silver prints, framed in black and matted, and hung in the main gallery space. The prints range in size from 7×9 and 8×10 to oversized exhibition prints at approximately 14×22. The images come from the period 1931 to 1961, and were taken in far flung locations all over the world. (Installation shots at right.)

Comments/Context: The photography of Henri Cartier-Bresson has been so thoroughly studied and documented, it seems unlikely that there are many new paths for exploration of his art open for adventurous souls. Cartier-Bresson is of course known as the master of the hand-held camera (a 35mm Leica) and perhaps the father of photojournalism. He was the founder of Magnum Photos and the coiner of the now hackneyed (but still relevant) phrase “the decisive moment”. His influence on photographers downstream from him has been nothing short of immense.

So the show of early prints at Edwynn Houk doesn’t even try to add to the mountain of pre-existing Cartier-Bresson scholarship (there is no wall text, no chronological grouping, no narrative or curatorial viewpoint), and seems satisfied to have simply gathered such a remarkable group of greatest hits. Given the scarcity of vintage prints of any of his images, much less the most famous images from his entire career, this exhibit must have required many years of relentless legwork to put together.

The durability of Cartier-Bresson’s images is the primary takeaway for me from this show. Many of these pictures have become so famous that they have become almost overexposed, like a song you’ve heard too many times. And yet, seeing many of these old favorites again in this show, many with the soft patina of age, they still seem fresh and alive, regardless of when they were taken. The second highlight (given the structure of this show) is of course his remarkable consistency. Across decades of time and vast differences in geography and subject matter, he repeatedly captured pictures of people that continue to resonate as being somehow both universal and unique at the same time. Wandering through this gallery is like coming upon a group of old friends, each one still a joy, and with news to tell.

The Fondation Henri Cartier-Bresson website can be found here. His page at Magnum Photos is here.

Collector’s POV: The images in this show are priced between $9500 and $90000, with two prints “price on request”. Cartier-Bresson’s prints are ubiquitous at auction (literally hundreds in any given year), but nearly all are later prints, and many are of more random documentary subjects, beyond his most famous pictures. While Cartier-Bresson’s pictures don’t fit into our particular collecting framework, it seems unlikely that so many superior quality prints will be brought together in one place again for a very long time, so put this show on your list to see before it closes.

Rating: ** (two stars) VERY GOOD (rating system described here)

Henri Cartier-Bresson, Early Prints
Through May 2nd

745 Fifth Avenue
New York, NY 10151
ADMINISTRATIVE NOTE: There will be no posts tomorrow (Wednesday, 4/8). Back to normal on Thursday.

Auction Results: Photographs and Photographic Editions, New York, April 2, 2009 @Bloomsbury

There aren’t many easy ways to sugar coat the results at Bloomsbury last week – it was a rough outing. Whether this was due to the material they collected, their place last in line after an exhausting run of AIPAD and the other auctions, the general economic malaise, or some combination of all three, the results were a dose of reality after a glimmer of optimism coming out of the big crowds at AIPAD. When half the lots fail to sell, it’s a splash of very cold water.

The summary statistics are below:

Total Lots: 140
Pre Sale Low Total Estimate: $559900
Pre Sale High Total Estimate: $832200
Total Lots Sold: 70
Total Lots Bought In: 70
Buy In %: 50.00%
Total Sale Proceeds: $333304

Here is the breakdown (using the Low, Mid, and High definitions from the preview post, here):

Low Total Lots: 132
Low Sold: 67
Low Bought In: 65
Buy In %: 49.24%
Total Low Estimate: $695200
Total Low Sold: $291214

Mid Total Lots: 8
Mid Sold: 3
Mid Bought In: 5
Buy In %: 62.50%
Total Mid Estimate: $137000
Total Mid Sold: $42090

High Total Lots: 0
High Sold: NA
High Bought In: NA
Buy In %: NA
Total High Estimate: NA
Total High Sold: NA

84.29% of the lots that sold had proceeds in or above the estimate range. While there were both photographs and photo books in this sale, they generally performed at about the same rate in terms of sell through. There were no surprises (defined as having proceeds of at least double the high estimate) in this sale.

Complete lot by lot results can be found here.

Bloomsbury Auctions
6 West 48th Street
New York, NY 10036

Tanyth Berkeley, Grace @Danziger

JTF (just the facts): A total of 11 color images, framed to the edge in either black or white, with no mat, displayed in the single room gallery space. Sizes range from 24×20 to 63×28 (full body size), and are printed in editions of 5. (Marginal installation shots at right.)

Comments/Context: I was first exposed to the work of Tanyth Berkeley at the New Photography 2007 exhibit at the MoMA, where her portraits had an electricity that monopolized the available attention. Continuing a line of thinking drawn back through Diane Arbus and Lisette Model, Berkeley makes realist portraits of unusual people with a sense of intimate care and genuine curiosity. She has pointed her camera at transgendered people, people with albinism, and a whole range of folks who fall outside society’s normal definitions of beauty, finding unique stories to tell in each and every one.
.
In the show at the MoMA, while there were plenty of startling full body portraits, I remember being completely awestruck by a smaller image of a woman named Grace, seated by a window with an ethereal light coming from behind, as though she was glowing. It was like a Renaissance portrait of a saint or angel, at the very moment of some kind of spiritual ecstasy. (Grace in Window, 2006, at right.) It struck me then, as it does now, as one of the best contemporary portraits I’ve seen in a very long time, likely to age well and remain inspiring over many years. As an aside, a print of this image went into the MoMA’s permanent collection.

This image is on display at Danziger Projects as part of larger body of Berkeley’s recent work focused on this woman. Grace Longoria’s albinism makes her skin and hair radiantly white, and she is often photographed with her eyes closed, due to her increased intolerance of bright light. The images in the show find her in different poses and clothes, but always with the same delicacy and fragility. Not all of the images rise to the same lofty heights as her portrait by the window, but clearly, the artist and muse have found a working relationship that allows them to take some risks.

Collector’s POV: The images in the show are reasonably priced between $2800 and $6800. Berkeley’s work doesn’t even remotely fit into our particular collection; contemporary color portraits are about as far from our specific genres as one could imagine.
But I can say with some conviction that I believe Grace in Window will end up being among the hallmark contemporary portraits of this decade. (Stop and digest that comment for a moment, as it’s a real whopper.) Since there is only one left, priced at $6800, if we were contemporary photography collectors looking for signature images from these times, I’d pick up the phone right now and put in on hold before it vanishes.
Rating: * (one star) GOOD (rating system described here)
Through April 25th
534 West 24th Street
New York, NY 10011

Izima Kaoru, New Work @Von Lintel

JTF (just the facts): A total of 8 color works on display: 7 large scale c-prints, framed in blond wood without mats, and 1 group of 4 smaller prints, mounted to plexiglass but not framed. The larger c-prints are approximately 70×94 or 70×60 and come in editions of 5. The smaller images are 20×26. (Installation shots at right.)

Comments/Context: Japanese photographer Izima Kaoru has been making images in his series Landscapes with a Corpse for a decade now. In each series, a famous Japanese actress or model imagines her perfect fantasy “death”, complete with the designer clothes she would be wearing at the time. Kaoru then creates the elaborate settings and makes pictures from a variety of cinematic distances: the close-up (eyes open), medium range images, and far away wide angle shots. The effect is an extremely elegant crime scene, the opposite of the grittiness of Weegee’s real life corpses in the gutter.

I first saw an image from this series several years ago, a huge print of a woman “dead” on the floor of a pachinko parlor, surrounded by neon pink chairs and fallen amidst a sea of silvery balls. I was taken aback by its over-the-top glamour and the lushness of its eye-popping colors. Nearly every review of Kaoru’s work is riddled with words like shocking and disturbing, morbid and repulsive. And yet, my reaction was and still is just the opposite. These images are, in my view, nothing more than an adult version of the play acting and dress up games of childhood, complete with couture gowns and lavish locations. I’m not sure these new works, which lack any visible signs of injury, would even be classified as unsettling.

In this small show, I particularly enjoyed the series of images called Sakai Maki wears Jil Sander, 2008, where a woman in a sheer salmon colored dress and sky blue shoes lies in a room full of white flowers. These works are dreamlike and calm, with a quirky surreal and conceptual feel that reminded me of Magritte. The other works on display are more straightforward in their settings, but equally serene and peaceful.

For Western audiences who have no familiarity with these Japanese actresses and models (like me), the individual people become more like beautiful mannequins (they’re supposed to be dead after all) in a carefully styled fashion shoot. I think if Julia Roberts or Kate Moss (or someone else equally recognizable here) were inserted instead of the Japanese women, I think the images might have a very different resonance.

Collector’s POV: The large images in the show are priced at either $22500 or $27000; the group of smaller images is $14000. In the secondary markets, Kaoru’s work has only just become available at auction in the last year, so there isn’t enough data to form any meaningful pricing pattern. While not every image in Kaoru’s large and growing project is a winner, a handful of stand out pictures can be found that would fit well in most contemporary collections.

Rating: * (one star) GOOD (rating system described here)

Izima Kaoru, New Work
Through April 25th

Von Lintel Gallery
555 West 25th Street
New York, NY 10001

Auction Results: Photographs, New York, April 1, 2009 @Phillips

Given the challenging times, the spring Photographs sale at Phillips De Pury & Company in New York performed surprisingly well. The total proceeds just missed the pre sale total Low estimate, coming much closer than either Sotheby’s or Christie’s had in the previous days. The larger number of lots of offer and the generally decent sell through rate vaulted Phillips into the second place spot for total proceeds this season.

The summary statistics are below:

Total Lots: 279
Pre Sale Low Total Estimate: $1995100
Pre Sale High Total Estimate: $2908000

Total Lots Sold: 187
Total Lots Bought In: 92
Buy In %: 32.97%
Total Sale Proceeds: $1890876

Here is the breakdown (using the Low, Mid, and High definitions from the preview post, here):

Low Total Lots: 204
Low Sold: 134
Low Bought In: 70
Buy In %: 34.31%
Total Low Estimate: $1061000
Total Low Sold: $708001

Mid Total Lots: 70
Mid Sold: 49
Mid Bought In: 21
Buy In %: 30.00%
Total Mid Estimate: $1347000
Total Mid Sold: $825625

High Total Lots: 5
High Sold: 4
High Bought In: 1
Buy In %: 20.00%
Total High Estimate: $500000
Total High Sold: $357250

A stunning 95.72% of the lots that sold had proceeds in or above the estimate range (with 32.62% above). Phillips clearly figured out the formula for setting estimates that were both enticing and generally on target in this more conservative economic environment.

There were plenty of surprises (defined as having proceeds of at least double the high estimate) in this sale: a total of 9 lots generated some bidding heat, although most were lower priced lots. Here’s the list: lot 4, Henri Cartier-Bresson, Island of Siphnos, Greece, 1961/later at $18750, lot 75, Bruce Weber, Zor and Zor’s Back, 1982, at $2500, lot 76, Bruce Weber, Matt, Marine from Mideast, 1983, at $2750, lot 82, Flip Schulke, Muhammad Ali boxing underwater, 1961/later at $12500, lot 116, David Drebin, Movie Star, 2004, at $16250, lot 178 Tina Modotti, Woman with Flag, Mexico City, 1928/posthumous 1992 at $9375, lot 183, Ernst Haas, Homecoming Prisoner, Vienna, 1946/later at $2750, lot 198, Cindy Sherman, Untitled (Madonna), 1975/later at $6250, and lot 215, Michael Kenna, Wind Swept Beach, Calais, France, 1999, at $6875.

Complete lot by lot results can be found here.

Phillips De Pury & Company
450 West 15th Street
New York, NY 10011

Myoung Ho Lee, Tree @Yossi Milo

JTF (just the facts): 8 color images, in various sizes, framed in blond wood with no mat and hung in the single main gallery space. The negatives are from the period 2005 to 2008. The prints are archival inkjet prints, in editions of 3. (Installation shots at right.)

Comments/Context: Traditional subject matter is a mine field for a young photographer; it is extremely difficult to make pictures that aren’t derivative or boring, given how many great photographers have walked the same road in the past. It is therefore exciting (and generally unexpected) when an emerging artist finds a new way into an old genre (trees, in this case), turning agreed upon conventions on their head and making us look at the subject with fresh eyes. The history of photography is brimming with great images of trees, going all the way back to the birth of the medium, but South Korean photographer Myoung Ho Lee has given us something different in his first solo show in the US, on view now at Yossi Milo.

Lee’s insight comes in the form of the simple white backdrop (think Richard Avedon) common to portraiture. Just as the blank canvas focuses our attention on the face of a portrait sitter, it has the same effect here when placed behind the graceful form of a tree – it sharpens our view of its shape, its texture, and its form. Lee has added a surprising conceptual twist to this idea by hanging the white sheeting in the context of the landscape that surrounds the tree, at once separating the tree from its normal environment, while at the same time giving the viewer some peripheral information about its usual context. Distracting wires and ropes are Photoshopped out later, leaving the sheet hanging strangely untethered in nature. The effect is a tunnel like vision of the isolated tree, highlighting its quirky individual personality, normally lost in the larger world around it.

The most striking image in the show is a large panorama of a single red Japanese maple (Tree #5, 2007, no longer available) against an expansive empty landscape, but nearly all of the works are visually intriguing, like stately still life portraits of weathered elders and younger up-and-comers.

Collector’s POV: Images in the show are priced between $3500 and $14000. While Lee’s conceptual twist made me think of Rodney Graham’s upside down trees, I think this straightforward idea (the neutral backdrop in nature) has some legs in terms of opening up a wide avenue for the artist to explore more fully. These images are easy to like and should go down well with collectors.

Rating: * (one star) GOOD (rating system described here)

Through April 18th

525 West 25th Street
New York, NY 10001

The Printed Picture @MoMA

JTF (just the facts): Several hundred objects, including framed and unframed works, fragments, color separations, and magnifications, displayed in multiple layers floor to ceiling in 5 rooms (with two partitions) on the third floor of the museum. The exhibit is organized chronologically, with each printing process explained via wall text and a handful of images. A reference volume, also entitled The Printed Picture, has been published in conjunction with the show. (Installation shots at right.)

Comments/Context: When I was a kid, from time to time, I would get it into my head that it would be a good idea to read our encyclopedia. So I would pull down a volume at random (say M) and start to read the entries. While the text itself was generally friendly and approachable in tone, it was so densely packed with information that I would soon be unable to absorb much more. I would then begin to skim the entries, working faster and catching only the high points. This too would eventually run out of momentum, and I would be reduced to flipping the pages and looking at the pictures, not internalizing much of anything. Finally, I would just give up and put the book back on the shelf until the next time.

This progression is an exact replica of my experience visiting The Printed Picture exhibit at the MoMA. The exhibit and accompanying book were conceived of and designed by Richard Benson, former Dean of the Yale University School of Art, and represent a lifetime of meticulous work documenting the changing technology and processes of printing. In many ways, this show is more like the kind you might find in a natural history or science & technology museum; it is unabashedly educational, the information delivered in an objective and practical manner, well ordered and comprehensive. Academically speaking, it is certainly one of the finest reviews of the process of printing across the ages that has ever been put forth.

The problem is that as an exhibition it is completely overwhelming. As a collector, I am particularly interested in the minutiae of various photographic processes, and I came into the exhibit especially focused on getting some answers to questions I have about recent color processes (digital inkjet prints) and their relationship to better known color methods of the 1970s (c-prints and dye transfer prints). But I started in the first room with my old encyclopedia reading method and was soon bogged down in too much information. By the time I got through daguerreotype, tintype, salt paper, woodburytype, gum bichromate, carbon, and albumen prints, my eyes were already starting to glass over, and I had just gotten started. On through blueprint (somehow not called cyanotype for some reason), gelatin silver, platinum, palladium, and Polaroid and over to the realms of color: autochrome, carbo, color carbon, chromogenic, dye transfer, Kodacolor, and early inkjet. After this group, I had reached my full point and had to sit down.

Unfortunately, the rest of the exhibit was a complete blur; I had moved on past skimming to outright page flipping, unable to absorb any more information. There is whole room devoted to magazine and book printing processes, including photogravure, etching, halftone, duotone, collotype, and offset lithography. The last room was the one I actually had come to see, but was too exhausted to enjoy by the time I got there; this was the room with the in depth discussion of digital chromogenic, pigmented inkjet, iris, dye sublimation, and laser writer color prints (among many others).

Benson has done an admirable job of making what could be a pretty dry subject more engaging, particularly through the use of the large magnifications, which show how the different technologies and approaches were used to generate tonal range. He shows relationships between current technologies and their predecessors, and presents each process in an even handed, matter of fact way. My conclusion is that this show is not much about art, but more about printing; the art objects used as examples are taken out of their context as art and placed into a more academic view of the processes, where the prints are examined for their grains and dots, not their composition or emotional quality. The nuances of printing have been explored in full here, and those who have a deep interest will likely revel in the exhaustive detail presented.

Collector’s POV: In my view, great exhibits are exciting and thought provoking, so much so that your brain sizzles for quite a while after your visit, replaying the wonders that were found there. Unfortunately, this exhibit, while utterly comprehensive and impressive, didn’t make my mind tingle; in fact, it was just the opposite – I was left worn, weary, and utterly defeated. So while the content of this show clearly deserves our highest rating, the show itself merits a lower grade in my subjective view, as the overall experience left me a walking zombie. I think the answer is to buy the book, and enjoy it for the well researched, useful reference tool that it is.
Rating: * (one star) GOOD (rating system described here)
Through July 13th

11 West 53rd Street
New York, NY 10019

Naoya Hatakeyama, Lime Works

JTF (just the facts): Published in 2008 by Seigensha Art Publishing. First edition by Seigensha, third edition overall. 120 pages, with 70 color plates. Includes a short essay by the artist. The images were taken in various locations all over Japan between 1986 and 1994.

Comments/Context: A little known fact about Japan is that it is one of the world’s largest suppliers of limestone, dug from quarries that dot the landscape up and down the archipelago. The rock is cut from the hillsides, and then pulverized into thick white dust that becomes a key component in cement and concrete. Most of the dense urban sprawl that is the stereotype of futuristic Japan is made from this cement.

Japanese photographer Naoya Hatakeyama spent many years traveling to distant limestone quarries all over the islands, making pictures of the landscape and the huge industrial structures built to process the material. The book begins with images of the chaotic aluminum buildings, covered with a staggering array of rusting conveyor belts, pipes, tubes and silos, and often coated with a soft frosting of white lime dust. Many are taken at twilight, when the colored lights are starting to come on and the sky is turning unexpected colors. His images then step back to take in a broader view of the land, with miniature trucks engulfed by the huge swaths of road and emptiness, gargantuan holes in the ground or terraced hillsides with stagnant pools of adjacent water. The last few images are highly textured pictures of natural outcroppings of jagged limestone. Together, they are a deadpan portrait of the transformations going on, void of any people.

Over the past few months, I have spent time with this book and have become more and more impressed with the pictures it contains. Given our affinity for industrial photography, it is perhaps not surprising that we would enjoy the vast images of factories, with their geometric forms and intersecting lines, particularly some of the ones that are detailed shots of abstract machinery encrusted in white. Beyond these, I have also come to appreciate the poignancy of the wider angle shots of the topographical changes at the quarries. Edward Burtynsky (among others) has elaborated on these ideas, but Hatakeyama’s images are somehow less harsh, often taken in the warm glow of the late afternoon.

There is a superb short video on the work of Naoya Hatakeyama (narrated by the artist himself), entitled The Skin of the City, at the JGS Forward Thinking Museum (here). It is well worth a few moments of your time. To find it, enter via the elevator and find the FTM Theater on the navigation device. Go there and look for the film, among the many available for viewing.

Collector’s POV: I can absolutely imagine adding work by Hatakeyama to our collection, given the terrific images in this book. The artist is represented in Japan by Taka Ishii Gallery (here); there was a show of his new work called “Maquettes/Light” on view in their Kyoto gallery (here) this past March. His work has only recently begun to be available sporadically in the secondary markets here in the US. Clearly, we will need to add more of Hatakeyama’s books to our library to further educate ourselves about this important photographer.

Auction Results: Photographs, New York, March 31, 2009 @Christie’s

If higher end buyers had shown up in more force at Christie’s yesterday, the results might have been quite a bit better than what actually occurred. 9 of the 15 high end lots (60%) were bought in, and when these big ticket items fail to sell, it drags down the whole endeavor. That said, the Low and Mid ranges performed solidly, and so overall, it was a reasonable, workmanlike performance, albeit with lower total proceeds than they probably would have liked or expected.

The summary statistics are below:

Total Lots: 115 (one lot withdrawn since preview post)
Pre Sale Low Total Estimate: $2273000
Pre Sale High Total Estimate: $3340000

Total Lots Sold: 82
Total Lots Bought In: 33
Buy In %: 28.70%
Total Sale Proceeds: $1554250

Here is the breakdown (using the Low, Mid, and High definitions from the preview post, here):

Low Total Lots: 15
Low Sold: 12
Low Bought In: 3
Buy In %: 20.00%
Total Low Estimate: $123000
Total Low Sold: $106000

Mid Total Lots: 85
Mid Sold: 64
Mid Bought In: 21
Buy In %: 24.71%
Total Mid Estimate: $1707000
Total Mid Sold: $1025500

High Total Lots: 15
High Sold: 6
High Bought In: 9
Buy In %: 60.00%
Total High Estimate: $1510000
Total High Sold: $422750

86.96% of the lots that sold had proceeds in or above the estimate range, so Christie’s is clearly fine tuning their estimates with more accuracy. There were two surprises (defined as having proceeds of at least double the high estimate) in this sale: lot 47, Henri Cartier-Bresson, Judith Martinez Ortega, Mexico, 1934 at $25000, and lot 116, William Eggleston, Untitled, 1973, from Los Alamos, at $18750.

Complete lot by lot results can be found here.

Christie’s
20 Rockefeller Plaza
New York, NY 10020

Sarah Thornton, Seven Days in the Art World

JTF (just the facts): Published in 2008 by W.W. Norton & Company. 274 pages. Divided into 7 chapters (roughly 30 pages each): The Auction, The Crit, The Fair, The Prize, The Magazine, The Studio Visit, and The Biennale.

Comments/Context: Sarah Thornton’s chronicle of the booming art world of a year or two ago might just as well be an anthropological study of an isolated tribe of the Amazon rain forest or some other far off locale. It is a piece of ethnographic writing, where the social and cultural behaviors of a group of people are described in depth, using thorough and careful “participant observation” (fly on the wall reporting) as the primary research method. This is not to say that this book is academic and boring; just the opposite in fact – it is well paced, gossipy at times, and generally highly entertaining. It is not, however, much about the art itself, but an in-depth study of the subcultures and social signals that make up the ecosystem that surrounds it.

As collectors ourselves, tangentially related to those described in these pages, the sections devoted to the study of auctions, art fairs, and the biennale didn’t offer us many new insights, as we have participated in these worlds first hand. That said, the auction section neatly describes the theatrical spectacle of an evening Contemporary Art sale at Christie’s, the fair section genuinely brings forth the wearying machinations of dealers, advisers and collectors at Art Basel, and the biennale section captures the idiosyncrasies of the national pavilions and the high end socializing.

I found more unexpected ideas and discoveries in the other sections. In The Crit, I was intrigued by the exhausting and mystifying full day critical review process that artists endure at CalArts, an amorphous, rambling and often painful discussion of an artist’s current output. In The Prize, the backstage workings of the selection committee for the Turner Prize turned out to be less interesting than the four nominees themselves and how they were handling the pressure and publicity. And given our own writing about photography on this site, I was particularly interested by the section on Artforum (The Magazine) and the perilous balancing act that goes on between writers/critics, editors and advertisers each month to get the magazine out and the care with which the magazine’s viewpoint is defended.

My favorite section in the book was was The Studio Visit, a sprawling review of Takashi Murakami’s multi-national production empire, on the eve of his now famous MOCA show which included the Louis Vuitton shop as part of the exhibit. While we have been on intimate studio visits before, the scale here is broad and monumental. While there are plenty of large personalities in this section as well (including Murakami himself), there is more about the art and its making in this chapter than anywhere else in the book. The artist’s process and management of his team of people are unusual and memorable.

Collector’s POV: Overall, this narrative is very well crafted and seems to have been thoroughly researched, given the huge list of interviewees in the back. It is very people-centric and often dives into the subtle gestures and remarks that epitomize the inner workings of a small social group. Think of it as quick and lively read, with plenty of tidbits to engage even the most experienced and jaded collectors.

The author’s website can be found here.

Conversation with Robert Frank @NGA

Modern Art Notes has an anecdotal summary of a public conversation last Friday between Robert Frank and National Gallery of Art photography curator Sarah Greenough, as part of the 50th anniversary exhibition of The Americans at the NGA. Find part 1 here and part 2 here. The exhibition website can be found here.

Hopefully, New Yorkers will get a similar opportunity to hear Frank when the show comes to the Met in September (here).

Auction Preview: Vintage & Contemporary Photography, April 18, 2009 @Heritage

Heritage Auction Galleries of Dallas, TX, entered the photography auction market last December with its inaugural sale, and is following up that effort with a solid offering this spring. In a time when consignments are scarce, it is quite surprising to see a new entrant deliver a big catalog with 293 lots of decent work. Lorraine Davis is leading the photography department at Heritage, and it appears that they are taking dead aim at Swann Galleries and the lower end of what Sotheby’s and Christie’s used to take, scooping up a broad and eclectic mix of lower end lots.

The sale itself has some intriguing blocks of images: 47 lots of dance pictures by Barbara Morgan, 63 lots of Central European modernity (including several Kicken portfolios), 3 NASA multi-panel panoramas, and several strong works by Robert Frank. While there is virtually no 19th century material, and the contemporary work is pretty thin, the sale has plenty of 20th century imagery worth digging through.
Heritage has a few quirks in its process worth mentioning. First, the catalog doesn’t have estimate ranges. Instead, “Minimum Bid” amounts are listed. These amount to the reserve price, and are often much lower than the normal price range for a specific image, sometimes set at zero (as an example, there are two Ed Ruscha images, recent prints of 1960s negatives, with a Gagosian provenance, with minimum bids of zero; it seems pretty unlikely that these will sell for fifty bucks each). While estimates are available from the department, there isn’t any public signalling about where the images “ought” to sell. On the positive side, there isn’t any subterfuge about the reserve, and no chandelier bids on behalf of the seller; if you bid the minimum and there are no other bids, you win. On the negative side, the buyer must do more homework to get comfortable about his/her bidding strategy (which he/she would likely have done anyway in most cases), assuming that the end price for many lots will have little or no relationship to the minimum bid price quoted.
The second quirk has to do with shipping. Heritage doesn’t do its own shipping; all they do is connect a buyer with a list of third party shippers (the local UPS store etc.). Buyers have to contact the third party shipper, make arrangements/payment directly, and have the lot released from Heritage to the shipper for packing etc. From my perspective, this is a MAJOR negative. While most times this will work adequately, this set-up introduces the potential for significant additional hassle and screw ups, for which Heritage takes no responsibility. We will have to do meaningful extra work to bird dog the process, which we have no interest in doing. As such, we will certainly bid on less lots at Heritage until this changes. Only those lots which we are extremely interested in will merit this potential headache.
Given the lack of estimates, our usual statistical analysis can’t be done as easily. As such, we’ve made a simple change: an $8000 minimum bid price will be the break point between Low and Mid (somewhat equivalent to our usual $10000 high estimate break point). The highest minimum price is $20000, which isn’t close enough to our normal $50000 break point for High lots, so there are no High lots in this sale by these definitions. There are a total of 293 lots of offer, with a total minimum bid price of $648500. Here’s the adjusted breakdown:
Total Low lots (minimum bid below $8000): 275
Total Low estimate (sum of minimum bids): $467500
Total Mid lots (minimum bid between $8000 and $40000): 18
Total Mid estimate: $181000
Total High lots (minimum bid above $40000): 0
Total High estimate: NA
For our particular collection, we liked the Margaret Bourke-White transmitting towers (lots 75024 and 75025), the Aaron Siskind wrought iron railing (lot 75026), the Ludwig Windstosser scaffolding (lot 75217), the Albert RengerPatzsch tubes (lot 75230), and the Ernst Fuhrmann flowers (lots 75270 and 75276).
The lot by lot catalog can be found here.
April 18, 2009

Heritage Auction Galleries

3500 Maple Avenue
17th Floor
Dallas, TX 75219

Sign up for our weekly email newsletter

This field is required.